25 Years of Experience | Beautiful, Unique & High-Quality Flooring Products

Laminate flooring: What makes it an ideal choice for homes?

Hardwood vs Vinyl vs Laminate Flooring Comparison

One of the most important decisions you will make about your home design is its flooring. It not only enhances your home’s aesthetic value but also reflects the floor’s durability, maintenance needs, and long-term value. The three most popular options are laminate vs vinyl vs hardwood flooring:

  • Hardwood (our best-selling flooring option)
  • Vinyl 
  • Laminate 

Each of these options has its own strengths and weaknesses, so a clear understanding of each option is required for making an informed decision. This guide provides a detailed overview of hardwood vs vinyl vs laminate flooring options with their pros, cons, and how much they cost, so let’s get into the details!

What Is Hardwood Flooring?

Hardwood flooring is made from solid wood planks milled from hardwood species like oak, maple, cherry, or walnut. It’s natural, timeless, and has been a staple of quality home design for generations. For the past 25 years, we’ve been flooring the beautiful homes of our clients with hardwood, and it instantly becomes everyone’s favorite!

You can find more about it here: https://stittsvillefloors.com/ 

Pros of Hardwood Flooring

  1. Timeless beauty & natural warmth (hardwood floors add richness and character that’s hard to match)
  2. Longevity and durability (it can last 50+ years with proper care)
  3. Can be refinished repeatedly (scratches and wear can be sanded out and refinished)
  4. Adds resale value (buyers often pay more for homes with real wood floors)
  5. Hypoallergenic (does not trap allergens like carpet can)

Cons of Hardwood Flooring

  1. High cost (both the material and professional installation are pricey)
  2. Moisture sensitivity (prone to warping or cupping with humidity or spills)
  3. Scratches and dents (though refinishable, soft woods can show wear)
  4. Requires professional install (DIY isn’t recommended for most people)
  5. Regular maintenance (periodic refinishing and care are a must)

General Costs in the USA

  • Material Cost: ~$5–$25+ per sq. ft., depending on species and quality. 
  • Installation: ~$4–$8+ per sq. ft. by professionals.
  • Total Installed: Typically $9–$24+ per sq. ft. for solid hardwood.

What Is Vinyl Flooring?

Vinyl flooring is a synthetic product made from PVC plastics engineered to mimic wood, stone, or tile. It comes in sheet vinyl, luxury vinyl plank (LVP), or luxury vinyl tile (LVT) formats. 

Pros of Vinyl Flooring

  1. Highly waterproof (ideal for bathrooms, kitchens, and basements)
  2. Affordable (among the least expensive flooring options)
  3. Low maintenance (easy to clean with regular sweeping/mopping)
  4. Wide design selection (realistic wood or stone looks available)
  5. Comfort underfoot (softer and quieter than hardwood and laminate)

Cons of Vinyl Flooring

  1. Less resale value ( it usually doesn’t appreciably increase home value)
  2. Can dent or scratch (heavy objects can leave marks)
  3. Not natural wood (lacks the authenticity of real wood)
  4. Potential VOC emissions ( lower-quality vinyl can emit chemicals)
  5. Heat sensitivity (can expand or contract with temperature changes)

General Costs in the USA

  • Material Cost: ~$0.50–$5 per sq. ft. for standard vinyl. 
  • Installation Cost: ~$2–$7 per sq. ft., depending on type.
  • Total Installed: Roughly $3–$13+ per sq. ft,. depending on vinyl quality.

What Is Laminate Flooring?

Laminate flooring is an engineered product made of multiple layers of synthetic material fused together. A printed photographic layer gives it the look of hardwood or tile, and a protective top layer resists wear. 

Pros of Laminate Flooring

  1. Budget-friendly (generally cheaper than hardwood and comparable to vinyl)
  2. Durable and scratch-resistant (tough surface layer)
  3. Easy installation (many products are DIY-friendly, click-lock)
  4. Realistic wood looks (good visuals for the price)
  5. Higher resale value than vinyl (better aesthetic boost)

Cons of Laminate Flooring

  1. Not fully waterproof  (susceptible to moisture damage)
  2. Cannot be refinished (once worn, it must be replaced)
  3. Noise issues (can sound hollow without underlayment)
  4. Less realistic up close (wood grain isn’t real wood)
  5. Lower resale value than hardwood

General Costs in the USA

  • Material Cost: ~$1–$7 per sq. ft. depending on quality.
  • Installation Cost: ~$2–$5 per sq. ft. 
  • Total Installed: Around $3–$8+ per sq. ft.

Final Verdict, Laminate vs Vinyl vs Hardwood Flooring​ Which Is Better?

Hardwood vs vinyl vs laminate, which is the best one?

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer, it depends on your priorities:

  • Best for Aesthetics & Home Value: Hardwood (timeless, natural, and adds more to resale value)
  • Best for Moisture & Durability: Vinyl (completely waterproof and low maintenance)
  • Best for Budget & Ease of Installation: Laminate (great look for the price and DIY-friendly)

If you’re willing to invest in beauty and longevity and care about resale value, hardwood wins, but it comes at a premium. If you need practical, worry-free flooring for kitchens, bathrooms, or rental homes, vinyl is often the best choice. If cost and DIY installation are your priorities, laminate hits the sweet spot.

  • Hardwood remains the gold standard for classic beauty and durability, but it’s also the most expensive and maintenance-intensive.
  • Vinyl floors are highly versatile, affordable, and excellent in moisture-prone spaces, but they don’t deliver the charisma or resale boost of real wood.
  • Laminate provides a solid compromise, good looks and low cost, but it doesn’t offer real wood authenticity or waterproof performance unless specially treated.

For expert installation and guidance on all flooring types in Ottawa, check out our Ottawa flooring contractor services.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which is better, hardwood, laminate, or vinyl?

There’s no universal “best”; it depends on your needs:

  • Hardwood: Best for aesthetics, longevity, and home resale value.
  • Vinyl: Best for water resistance, low maintenance, and budget.
  • Laminate: Best for DIY installation, scratch resistance, and moderate cost.

So the best choice varies by priorities: style and value (hardwood), moisture and ease (vinyl), or cost and install-ease (laminate).

2. What is the “rule of 3” in flooring?

The Rule of 3 is a design guideline suggesting you should use no more than three different types of flooring in a home. It helps create visual harmony and flow between spaces, for example, hardwood in living areas, tile in bathrooms, and carpet in bedrooms.

3. What is the healthiest flooring for a home?

The healthiest flooring options typically:

  • Have low chemical emissions (low-VOC)
  • Do not trap dust and allergens

Some of the healthiest choices include:

  • Solid hardwood, naturally hypoallergenic and easy to clean
  • Natural materials like bamboo, cork, stone, tile, or linoleum
  • Certified low-VOC vinyl or laminate, safer versions of synthetic floors

Hard surfaces are often better for allergy sufferers than carpet because they don’t hold dust or pet dander.

4. What is the disadvantage of vinyl flooring?

Common disadvantages include:

  • Can be scratched or dented by heavy furniture or sharp objects
  • Lower resale value compared to hardwood
  • Difficult to repair, damaged planks usually need replacement
  • Environmental concerns with lower-quality products
  • Heat or sunlight exposure can cause fading or expansion over time

5. Is hardwood cheaper than laminate?

No. Hardwood is typically more expensive than laminate in both materials and installation. Laminate is one of the most budget-friendly flooring options.

6. What is the rule of 3 flooring?

It’s a design rule that recommends keeping no more than three different floor types in a home to maintain a cohesive and balanced look throughout the space.

7. Which is better, hardwood, laminate, or vinyl?

To recap:

  • Hardwood: best for long-term value and luxury appeal
  • Vinyl:  best for waterproofing and easy maintenance
  • Laminate: best for budget-friendly upgrades and DIY installs

The right choice depends on your home, lifestyle, and where the flooring will be installed.

8. Which is more expensive, hardwood or vinyl?

Hardwood is more expensive than vinyl. Hardwood flooring generally costs more in both material and professional installation, while vinyl remains one of the most affordable options.

READ MORE BLOG ARTICLES